Friday, April 27, 2012

Marine sergeant booted for criticism of Obama

President of the United States of America
and  Commander in Chief

On Thursday Stars and Stripes reported:
SAN DIEGO — A Marine sergeant who criticized President Barack Obama on Facebook pages is being dismissed from the service with an other-than-honorable discharge, the Marine Corps announced Wednesday.
Brig. Gen. Daniel Yoo accepted the unanimous recommendation of an Administrative Separation Board at Camp Pendleton that Sgt. Gary Stein be dismissed for making disparaging comments about the commander in chief that were disruptive to “good order and discipline” and violated military law.
Stein, 26, a nine-year veteran who served in Iraq, had called Obama a coward and an enemy, vowed not to salute him and called for his defeat in this year’s election. One of the websites was an Armed Forces Tea Party page on Facebook that was created by Stein, who sought to sell bumper stickers printed with “NOBAMA 2012.”
Stein’s civilian lawyers had sought to have his discharge blocked in federal court on grounds that his First Amendment rights were being violated by the Marine Corps. A federal judge in San Diego refused their request but the lawyers have vowed to appeal to the 9th Circuit.
Stein was informed of the general’s decision Wednesday. It will take at least a week for the administrative paperwork to be completed, a Marine spokesman said.
Yoo is commanding general of the Marine Corps Recruit Depot San Diego. A weather forecaster, Stein had recently lost his security clearance and was working as a scheduler on the rifle range at Camp Pendleton.
A Marine spokesman said Yoo “found the (separation) board was conducted in accordance with law and regulation, that the findings of misconduct were supported by the evidence of record, and thus approved the board’s recommendation.”
Stein is being demoted to lance corporal. His discharge status will make him ineligible for veterans benefits. The separation board was comprised of a lieutenant colonel, a major and a sergeant major.

Food for thought:
It looks like this young Marine forgot he was in the military, where it's a violation of military law to criticize the military's Commander in Chief!


Steve said...

The bottom line is he was warned he was in violation of the UCMJ and given multiple opportunities to adjust his conduct. He had an agenda and tried to manipulate the system in order to win his ten minutes of fame. What's more, he swore an oath and willingly violated it. The simple fact is that he worked hard for his punishment and earned every painful bit of it.

Syneeda said...

Steve, I was surprised at his defense, "My 1st amendment right was violated". Dah, everyone in the military knows it's a UCMJ offense to disrespect the Commander in Chief. He had an agenda and now he can exercise his 1st amendment right all he wants!

Anonymous said...

This guy was an idiot!!

ArmyVetRich said...

If you are serving in any branch of the US Armed Forces, you must respect the Commander In Chief, even if you intensely dislike his policies. Stein should have kept his mouth shut, like many other members of the US Armed Forces who share a similar opinion of The President. Ex-Sergeant Stein is now paying the price for making disparaging remarks about the Commander In Chief, and deserved to be punished under the Military Code of Military Justice, and you just heard that from an HONORABLY DISCHARGED Army Vet.